
Vegan
American
Beer/Wine
mushroom-based dishes
A vegan restaurant run by Overthrow Hospitality, that serves beer and a menu entirely focused on mushroom-based dishes. The parent website for Overthrow Hospitality makes it clear that all is plant-based. Formerly known as & Beer. Open Tue-Sun 5:00pm-10:00pm.
28 Reviews
First Review by Tucker333
nadine29
Points +2
All mushroom, all vegan - Edit
Yes, every dish is mushroom-based. No, they don’t all taste the same. Every dish is so unique you really forget you are eating mushrooms your whole meal. The lion’s mane dumplings are delicious but the beech “Mac n cheese” is definitely my favorite. A nice cozy spot!
Read morePros: Unique, Cozy atmosphere, Delicious
Guest
criticalj
Points +85
Unique experience for mushroom lovers - Edit
Overall, dining here was a creative, unique experience but I wouldn’t recommend it unless you’re really into mushrooms and want to spend $20 per dish
Read moreThe ambiance was fun and mushroom-themed and our serve was pretty inattentive toward us (but not the other tables). This is a tapas-style restaurant so it’s expected that you’ll share everything. For 2 people, we ordered the lion’s mane dumplings, beech mac cheese and the king royal trumpet ravioli.
The Beech and King royal trumpet were our favorites and we wanted to order more, but for the price, we couldn’t justify it. We went for pizza after 😅
Updated from previous review on 2025-05-29
Pros: Creative menu
Cons: Service was inattentive, Price for the food
Guest
anthonymhill
Points +1098
Great vegan mushroom dishes - Edit
If you love mushrooms, you’ll love this place. Just like me. Everything was great. Very cozy and a nice environment for dinner. Will be going back again soon.
Read moreGuest
pavanman5000
Points +73
ramen too salty, mushrooms overcooked, - Edit
im just disappointed. the mushrooms were chewy. that’s easy to do. anyone can do that. bring out their flavor without overcooking them. what’s the point
Read moreGuest
KristianaGeorgieva
Points +484
Great food - Edit
Lovely atmosphere, delicious food and the dessert was brilliant. Don't miss out on the bar its connected to for some great beer too
Read morePros: Food, Ramen, Dessert
Guest
hazelanne
Points +183
Outstanding! - Edit
Truly the most innovative and delicious meal I have ever had. Loved the beech and maitake as well as the incredible rosemary and porcini ice cream
Read morePros: Gorgeous decor, Service, Everything on the menu!
Guest
hnn1
Points +429
Great flavors - Edit
The dishes I ordered had such unique flavors! My favorite was the maitake, the celery root puree with the mushroom was delicious. I also ordered the yellow enoki dish, which was a lovely salad with excellent flavors. The only thing about it was that the enoki had an unpleasant texture. I hope it was just a fluke with my dish because the components of the salad with the almond and orange balsamic vinaigrette was really tasty. I loved the dessert, it was so perfect for me. I’m not a huge chocolate fan but the cake was not overwhelmingly rich, with the berry sauce and the light ice cream it was delicious. Loved this concept!
Read moreGuest
kubap
Points +94
Intriguing and flavorful - Edit
All dishes are intended to be shared, plenty of GF options (all but 3 items on the menu could have been made GF as of March ‘25), and everything really made of mushrooms. From noodle-like texture to creamy and flavorful sauces and dessert with candied mushrooms, very enjoyable. Fresh coconut water straight from the coconut was a wonderful compliment.
Read moreGuest
ElissaBVegan
Points +3368
Spectacular!!! - Edit
This is heaven for mushroom fans. Everything we ordered was super-delicious! The service was friendly and the atmosphere was charming. Highly recommend!
Read moreUpdated from previous review on 2025-02-24
Pros: All vegan , Creative mushroom dishes , Great atmosphere
Guest
BeanThereDownedThat
Points +194
Total package - Edit
The food was amazing, as was the service and ambience. Can't wait to go back and try every dish on the menu!
Read moreIf these fancy mushroom dishes were at other restaurants, they would cost twice as much.
There were some dishes that were beautiful mushrooms at the center of the plate, and others that had chopped up mushrooms in something where you couldn't taste them as much. They were all great, but I preferred the former. I just felt like these fancy mushrooms are too beautiful to dice up, but I also guess that what I'm proposing is too limiting for the chef. See, this place really gets you thinking! One small esoteric problem is that it's a little hard to tell from the menu which one of the two styles you're ordering.
Anyways, can't wait to try more dishes!
Updated from previous review on 2025-01-26
Pros: Food , Service, Ambience
Guest
RavishingRavenous
Points +3300
Wow... All Mushroom Dishes - Edit
Completely blown away by the mushroom-based dishes at @thirdkingdomnyc with Executive @chef_juan_xaltepex_ , an @overthrowhospitality restaurant among one of our favs @sodaclubnyc, @avantgardennyc, and many more!
Read moreWe absolutely loved everything we tried:
- Lions Mane Dumplings
- Beech Mushrooms in Cauliflower Cream
- Chantarelles in Cilantro Sauce
- Fried Enoki Ramen with fresh House Made Noodles in a creamy Sesame Coconut Cashew Broth ( My husband greatly enjoyed this one without me since I am allergic to cashews ) Thank you @allende_chef for the recommendation!
- Lava Cake with Rosemary and Porchini Ice Cream with Candied Shitake
I cannot recommend this place enough for such innovative and delicious mushroom dishes. And I am obsessed with the mushroom decor! And if you are not a mushroom person, have you tried good or different types of mushrooms?
Being vegan has opened my mind to try so many new foods and cuisines. I had this negative perception of mushrooms growing up as a kid... gross looking... slimy... but once you try a good mushroom or the different variety of mushrooms, you might pleasantly surprised!
Guest
LanceW
Points +169
Anyways... - Edit
It took us a while to pinpoint how to describe Third Kingdom. What we came up with, about an hour into the discussion, was that this is an overpriced appetizer restaurant with great tasting, all mushroom dishes. Not dishes featuring mushrooms, but mushrooms with a light sprinkle of other ingredients. Mushrooms. So many mushrooms.
Read moreIf you're considering dining here, do it. Mushrooms. It's a great experience that you won't repeat. Once you're done and you're wondering where to get an actual dinner that isn't just mushrooms, I would suggest Double Zero, about a 5 minute walk away. Mushrooms. Mushrooms.
So many mushrooms.
Guest
NYCswimmer
Points +776
Outstanding mushroom restaurant - Edit
Very creative mushroom dishes. Outstanding sauces and combinations. Ramen and lobster were probably my favorites. But really everything was exceptional
Read morePros: Ramen , Lobster, Peppino
Cons: Desert was good but not as great as the rest, Porcini ice cream was too sweet
Guest
js-toronto
Points +1352
A unique meal - Edit
I was so excited to come here because I love the concept. Everything we had was delicious although some things were a bit too salty. Main complaint is that the dishes are designed for sharing but the ramen was not at all shareable (we weren’t even given our own bowls - I guess we were supposed to eat out of the same one??). The king royal mushroom is the instagrammable, beautifully presented dish. Unfortunately that one was chewy and hard to cut and had the least mushroom flavour of all the dishes. The dessert was great. I would go back to try more but it was very expensive and didn’t wow me like other restaurants in the city.
Read morePros: Presentation, Fun concept, Some dishes were absolutely delicious
Cons: Overpriced, Very dark and noisy
Guest
laurenjach
Points +248
Great way to explore different mushrooms - Edit
I really enjoyed the dining experience here. The dishes are on the smaller side so between 3 of us we ordered 6 plates but the dessert. We might have ordered too much though, I think 4-5 plates and a dessert would have been enough. Each dish was really unique. The Lion’s mane dumplings were my favorite
Read moreGuest
scootiepatootie
Points +72
Creative and fun and delicious - Edit
This place is great ambience, food and service. We had morel, maitake, enoki salad and lions mane dumplings. Dumplings were favorite. Wish we got the dessert it looked so good in person. Also every table seemed to get the ravioli and love it.
Read moreUpdated from previous review on 2024-08-05
Guest
talakoala
Points +1083
Absolutely insane. - Edit
Every dish was fantastic. The dessert was incredible. Such a great experience.
Read morefutureghosts
Woah!! I need to go there!!
Read moreGuest
rtnc68
Points +949
Mushrooms - Edit
Definitely worth trying. Food was interesting and fun.
Read moreGuest
chels2ocean
Points +1343
So so delicious! - Edit
This was one of my favorite meals in a long time! Amazing what they do with mushrooms here. It is pricy for sure and plates are small (they recommend at least 2 or 3 per person) but very worth it for a special occasion!
Read moreGuest
Menna
Points +137
Now permanent! Mmmushrooms! - Edit
I booked, thinking that I was glad to get a date before (I had been led to believe) the pop-up would be closing... I'm so glad it is not!
Read moreThe moody room lent character, the quirky mushroom decor added fun...
A wonderful journey in mushrooms! All was ab fab and I particularly enjoyed the candied shitake and porcini ice cream with the lava cake (I would rarely ever order ice cream/toffee/caramel/treacle desserts - all too sweet, I find). Curiously creative, the flavour pairing of choc and mushroommm... - who knew!
(Yes, I admit: I'm a fan of pineapple on pizza...a fan of sweet with savoury!)
The friendly staff explained that the restaurant was no longer a pop up, and would not be closing down.
Gentle reminder: please check that your guests like mushrooms.
(It didn't seem fun for the guest who openly didn't like mushrooms, as we noticed in the group on the next table celebrating a birthday...)
Pros: Creative, Gastronomic, Unique
Guest
vegandinosaur
Points +529
Mushrooms galore - Edit
It was good! But there was almost too much creativity with the mushrooms. I liked the dumplings and the ramen… but the porcini ice cream was a bit too savory.
Read moreGuest
JJones315
Points +2325
Excellent and Unsual - Edit
Attended their Valentine's Day Dinner (5 courses + dessert) and was VERY impressed by the variety and the tastiness of each dish. In addition to the actual food, the service as attentive (and on a busy night) the price was very reasonable for the quality of the dining experience. They have small but varied wine and cocktail list, as well as non-alc beverages.
Read moreRUN don't walk to this wonderful restaurant!
Pros: Excellent food!, Nice service, Reasonable price for the quality
Guest
Walktell
Points +1026
Creative and Delicious - Edit
Go to this mushroom pop up while you still can! We were a group of 4 friends who like to share, 2 vegan 2 plant-forward omnivores we ordered one of everything.
Read moreThe first 2 plates were lion's mane dumplings and the beer battered oyster mushrooms they both were 'as expected' - they were very good but as you'd imagine tempura mushroom & dumplings would taste.
Things got exciting when the beech and hen of the woods plates came out. Beech was creamy & cauliflower 'cheesy' and hen of the woods with celery root puree was sublime!
Next the ravioli and the morel with curry grits, 2 of the more Instagramable dishes, just beautiful, the raviol texture was almost like an empanada due to a slightly crunchy bottom but still yummy, the curry grits were so good!! And the little balsamic pearls were wild, just bursting with sweet, tangy flavor.
Then came my favorite dish, the silver dollar with mushroom gratin and the final 2 entrees: the blue oyster with celery & fennel porcini puree was excellent and reminded me of my Mom's mushroom gravy. The finale of baby trumpet with mole de pipian was good, the strong flavor wasn't my favorite but my friends loved it, the mushroom looked surprisingly like salmon fillet.
Leave room for this! It was so unusual, tortellinis were filled with chocolate truffle sauce garnished with yummy little candied mushrooms!
The space is small 1 table in the window that seats 5, the rest is bar seating on tall bar stools.
2/7/24 Excited to be back with the mushroom menu permanent, now called Third Kingdom and swapped spaces to be the much bigger venue with Proletariat bar in the small & Beer space.
I'll keep it short and sweet this time, everything was amazing, some new menu items others were carried over, the curry grits with balsamic pearls still outstanding and the mole still not my favorite, definitely get the enoki starter and whatever the special foraged mushroom dish is. I went with a Flexitarian and an Omnivore and they both said it was one of the best meals they've ever had. We loved the wine we ordered and the service was impeccable! I am going back in 2 weeks with more friends!
Updated from previous review on 2024-02-11
Pros: Unique vegan dining experience, Delicious mushroom menu , Cool atmosphere
Guest
lulutmlnsn
Points +243
yummy !! - Edit
i think in order to get the full experience u rly need to try most of the dishes if not all of them. she and i both got the thai coconut drink and it was so refreshing and natural. we both got refills when we finished them lol. we started w the lions main dumplings and they werent rly my thing [ a bit too smoky and tough when i like my dumplings delicate and soft lol ] but my friend rly loved them. then we got the beech dish and we totally ate the entire thing. i was shocked it was all mushroom and tht there were no noodles. it was delicious but very heavy. we both felt like we were nine months pregnant and ready to deliver by the time we were done w this one lol. the hen of the woods was much lighter in comparison and i also wasnt a major fan but i did rly like the celery root puree w the pickled hon shimeji. it was so refreshing after the rich and cheesy beech dish. then the lobster was mainly for my friend bcs i dont like curry v much but i still had a taste. not my thing but i can see how ppl wld like it. my friend liked it but shes more of a green curry girl and not a big fan of yellow curries. we finally had the blue oyster and it was definitely the best. i loved everything ab it im totally reminiscing on the taste rn. then the dessert was actually a bit of a let down surprisingly. we were super excited bcs it was this porcini ice cream tht was v interesting and i liked it but it was such a small element on the plate tht i wished there was less of everything else and more of it. there was this chocolate lava cake tht felt completely irrelevant bcs this restaurant revolves arnd mushrooms. it felt strange tht the star of the dessert was this decadent chocolate cake [ which was rly good to b clear ] tht had nothing to do w mushrooms. there were also these candied shiitake mushrooms tht were rock hard lol. my friend and i were laughing ab how it felt like we were gonna break a tooth on one ... and then the blueberry sauce was yet another variable tht didnt make sense. idk lol. overall i wished they had highlighted the ice cream bcs it was the most interesting and inventive. all in all , it was a delicious meal w v few flaws. thank u so much for the delicious the dinner !!💗
Read moreUpdated from previous review on 2023-11-21
Pros: YUMM + beautiful plating, rly nice atmosphere, kind , knowledgeable staff
Cons: dessert felt somewhat confused, pricey
LanceW
Man that's a tough review to read, grammatically speaking. 🙄
Read morelulutmlnsn
so dont read it. my grammar isnt the issue. i j type w a lot of abbreviations.
Read moreGuest
little_vegan_brie
Points +622
Yes mushrooms - Edit
Amazing experience at &beer this past weekend. Hoping they make it a permanent thing 🤞🏻
Read moreWe got the lions mane dumplings (don’t miss these!), the hen of the woods (also great, lots of flavors), the ravioli (the prettiest & tastiest dish), & the blue oyster (heavier fare, not my favorite). Almost got dessert, but didn’t have time before our next engagement. We will be back!
Great beer & wine selection as well!
Pros: Unique dishes , Cool ambiance
Cons: Pricier
Guest
DC Vegan
Points +341
For mushroom lovers only - Edit
If you're a beer fan (I'm not) or a mushroom fan (I absolutely am), this is the place for you! My boyfriend and I were visiting NYC recently and had to check it out. &Beer is part of the Overthrow Hospitality group, a collection of vegan bars and restaurants around the East Village. We arrived on a Friday evening and entered a narrow restaurant (because the address is split into two restaurants) with bar seating, but we were able to get a small table with fairly comfortable barstools.
Read moreSince I'm not a beer person, I ordered an Italian soda, which, although a bit expensive, was very nice to have with my meal. &Beer is the sort of place where you order dishes for the table and share them, and the servers at those places always recommend you get more dishes than you can eat. We stuck with three items, the Hen of the Woods, which I think was my favorite; the White Silver Dollar; and the Blue Oyster, which came with a grilled onion, another way to make me happy. Everything was really good, and three dishes between my boyfriend and me proved ample.
There is one dessert item, a chocolate truffle tortellini, and it was certainly interesting.
I saw that &Beer is listed as a pop-up, but I do hope they stick around because I sure would love to come back the next time I'm in NYC.
Pros: All vegan, Really good food
Cons: Very small space, A bit expensive
Guest
mazinha
Points +331
So much fun! - Edit
If you’re a mushroom lover, you have to try this place. Even the dessert is mushroom-based and quite good!
Read morePros: Mushrooms!
Guest
For Members
Why was my review removed? Guidelines for writing a review View our privacy policyFor Business Owners
Claim this business
See inaccurate information? Submit an update here Link to this page from your site See an unfair review? View full terms & conditionsThis page has been viewed 0 times.