Welcome! Let's get this started.
Finish logging in.
Makes vegan pizzas with cheese toppings including cashew mozzarella, parm, and almond ricotta. Can add toppings like house-made vegan honey, sausage, pepperoni, and veggies. Previously known as The Local Plant Based Pizza Co. Available on Grubhub, UberEats and DoorDash for local delivery. Check Instagram for weekly specials and changes to hours. Relocated from 554 N New St. Open Wed-Sat 12:00pm-8:00pm. Closed Sun-Tue.
-
125 E 3rd St, Bethlehem, Pennsylvania, USA, 18015
-
Loading...
-
- Wheelchair accessible
- Accepts credit cards
-
-
Last update on 12 May 2026 by MarcKubushefski
Update business info -
Added by KarleeRapp on 06 Dec 2021
-
-
47 Reviews
First Review by LaurenOliver
leakim
Points +2154
Pizza for all - Edit
Fun find when you have a craving for pizza. Lots of pizza choices or build your own. Also lots of sandwich choices.
Read morePizzas are large at 18"! Great for sharing or taking home. Takes 20 min or so for pizza to be made, so be patient.
Rating 5-stars, but the flavor was a bit lacking for me and could have used a bit more on the toppings.
Guest
MissyEVeggie
Points +98
Vegan pizzeria with a goth twist - Edit
Incredibly good (and big) pizza - great crust and sauce - plus lots of toppings. Interesting (in a good way) selection of other pizzeria items. Goth twist can be seen in the photos.
Read moreUpdated from previous review on 2026-08-18
Pros: Generous and quality toppings, Friendly staff, Large and unique selection of menu items
Cons: Could not eat the entire pizza (con? ;-), Would like more drink options
Guest
camrynxoxo22
Points +40
Best Vegan Pizza Ever - Edit
I’ve been getting paranormal pizza consistently (at least twice a month) for about a year now and the quality is out of this world. The pizza is delicious, the seitan wings are always a hit, and their other apps and sandwiches have so much flavor. My boyfriend and I absolutely love it here and are die-hard fans. Also, the people who run this place are so kind and truly put their whole heart into this business 🫶🏻
Read moreUpdated from previous review on 2026-08-16
Guest
KristaNicole
Points +137
A must stop anytime you are near Bethlehem - Edit
Full vegan menu, excellent one of a kid choices. Appetizers, Sandwiches, Pizza.
Read morePros: Unique combinations, Excellent sauces, Plenty of proteins
Cons: Street parking (free Sunday)
Guest
talakoala
Points +1350
Insanely good - Edit
Best vegan pizza I’ve had in a while. Ridiculously good buffalo sauce.
Read moreUpdated from previous review on 2026-07-12
Guest
Keyz2026
Points +6668
Bethlehem Pizza Spot - Edit
The Deep Dish Detroit Pizza was good. The garlic knots were good. The peach chipotle wings are really good. The owners were great.
Read moreGuest
MaggieSmith
Points +51
Epic pizza - Edit
Delicious pizza and garlic knots. Very good vegan cheese and meat.
Read moreReally nice and knowledgeable staff.
Very good vegan and gluten free pizzas as well.
Updated from previous review on 2026-05-28
Pros: Delicious food
Guest
ntk717
Points +283
Good food good people - Edit
Paranormal Pizza has an excellent menu with no wrong choices. Pizza by the slice or a whole pie, sandwiches and delicious sides. Very creative options by wonderful people.
Read moreUpdated from previous review on 2026-04-12
Pros: Great food, Friendly owners and staff, Provides options beyond the norm.
Guest
DTS
Points +1843
Wonderful wings &pizza - Edit
Had the buffalo wings and pizza with mushrooms, basil and sausage. Fun decor and fantastic friendly service
Read moreUpdated from previous review on 2026-03-15
Guest
slikespizza
Points +1906
Good Wings And Pizza - Edit
Had some lightly fried wings in a tasty buffalo sauce followed by an excellent thin crust pizza. Nice place with adequate seating and good service.
Read moreUpdated from previous review on 2026-03-15
Guest
Aly&Sean
Points +2009
Yum - Edit
The hot "honey" pepperoni pizza was delicious. Thought the cheese sticks were going to be like mozzarella sticks but it's basically cheesy garlic bread, very good!
Read moreGuest
QuinSavoy
Points +35
2 trips in one day!! - Edit
Garlic parm wings were the best vegan wings I've had in my 7yrs of being vegan. The flavor and texture are on point. The slice of pepperoni didn't disappoint! Now about these steaks! Had both and all ima say these need NATIONAL attention!! I'm from Philadelphia so I can talk. Vegan or not these steaks are the best! When in Bethlehem make sure you stop.
Read morePros: Food, Spacious, clean and relaxed atmosphere, The staff
Cons: There's no Lancaster location 🤣, They don't doordash to Lancaster 🤣, No real dislikes
Guest
stslj01
Points +1243
Always amazing. - Edit
Consistently amazing. Whether you get pizza, wings, or a sandwich, they do not disappoint. Food is so good, you find yourself questioning how it could be vegan. Servings are a good size. My friend and I ordered knots and cheese sticks and couldn’t believe the quantity we got. Leftovers abound! New location is easy to get to with both street parking and nearby parking lots. Plenty of seating inside.
Read moreUpdated from previous review on 2026-02-08
Guest
klhunter42
Points +500
Amazing pizza - Edit
All vegan menu. You can get Detroit or New York style in all varieties and build your own. All pizzas are named under X Files themed ideas. We got the Lone Gunmen in New York style and built our own Detroit style and ate for a few days 🤣
Read morePros: All vegan menu, Easily customizable, Cool space
Guest
Rave
Points +378
Great!! - Edit
Thank god they opened again- delicious!!!
Read moreUpdated from previous review on 2026-01-09
Guest
Kay2theTee
Points +98
Xfiles & pizza!! - Edit
Love the restaurant theme and the pizza special was delicious! Also had the seitan wings with their weekly sauce, very tasty with great texture. Can’t wait to go back
Read moreUpdated from previous review on 2026-01-05
Guest
mbabec
Points +334
Incredible pizza - Edit
Love coming here for the food. Everything I have ever had here is delicious but the pizza is the star of the show. Highly recommend.
Read moreGuest
michele6952
Points +458
The pizza alone is 5 stars! Omnis agree! - Edit
Have loved their pizzas since the beginning! Much better than most pizza shops in this area who aren't vegan. Now they've ventured into Calzones & sandwiches! Got our first ChikN calzone today & it far exceeds expectations!
Read moreUpdated from previous review on 2022-04-16
Pros: Quality, Freshness, Small local business
Guest
Tmoss682
Points +5027
Incredible Pizza - Edit
I’ve eaten pizza all over Italy, New York, Philly and more. This is the best pizza I’ve ever had. The crust is the shining part; Although, the entire pizza is great. Must try for anyone with a mouth: vegan or not. Garlic know crust is a must. I love the specials of the week; It speaks to the staff’s love for creative food making. I have not tried the extra menu items, but I look forward to it.
Read morePros: Unbelievable pizza, Welcoming pizzeria atmosphere, Knowledgeable and welcoming staff
Guest
laura8it
Points +745
Best wings of my life!! - Edit
I planned a trip to Bethlehem for Vegan Treats, but this was an added bonus! The garlic parm wings (on special) were the best I’ve ever had. They were perfectly chewy and the sauce was incredible. I ate the entire plate by myself, so didn’t have a ton of room for the Alien Bounty Hunter pizza, but I did my best! The pizza was good and incredibly heavy (weight wise). I really liked their cheese, and the garlic knots were a great change from normal crust. I actually think the pizza was better leftover, which was fortunate because I ate it for the next three days!!!
Read moreGuest
tarynhipp
Points +16
Best pizza in the Valley - Edit
The pan pizza is my favorite but the wings are also awesome. Actually, it’s all awesome just like everyone who works here! A must visit for anyone who loves pizza!
Read moreGuest
theveganreg
Points +396
Garlic knot crust is a must - Edit
Really great pizza, amazing seitan wings. Cool vibe. Get the garlic knot crust!!!
Read moreUpdated from previous review on 2022-09-11
Pros: Garlic knot crust, Cool vibe
Guest
PC12345
Points +177
Great Pizza - Edit
I was there only once because they are 'new' to the area and I live 1.5 hours away. The pizza was good- no complaints about any of it. It was tasty and the crust was chewy and just plain good.
Read moreThe waitstaff was fine, because it was not busy, I had the chance to just chat with them about vegan food (Sweet Treats bakery and other places in Philadelphia area).
I will go back to this place again when I get up that way again.
Pros: Delicious pizza, Nice staff, Prices are what I would expect
Cons: they are too far from me
Guest
vegan_homegirl
Points +591
Nice to have a legit vegan pizza place - Edit
Very unique and impressive photogenic pizzas. When this place popped up on my instagram I was like wow I must go here. So I do think I hyped it up in my head a bit too much hahah. However, very yummy quality pizza and the garlic knot crust is very cool! In terms of price it is definitely worth it. The pizzas are huge I ate leftovers for like 4 days haha.
Read morePros: “Real” vegan pizza, Options you cant get anywhere else, Big portions
Guest
Citizenmel
Points +61
Best Pizza, vegan or not - Edit
I’m from New York and this pizza is fantastic- dough itself is top notch, chewy, flavorful, and well risen . Then the toppings- oh! What combinations! We had a white pie, with garlic, chik’n, mozzarella, and a chili agave drizzle- wow! Still thinking about it the next day and wish we lived closer. Run, don’t walk, and support this wonderful vegan business
Read morePros: All vegan pizza and apps, Best crust anywhere, Fun theme
Cons: Only 16” pies, no slices, No plates for eating in
Guest
squash
Points +103
Great Food — Great People - Edit
We enjoyed great wings, both buffalo and mango habanero —they were spicy, crispy, and full of flavor.
Read moreThe pizza was also really good. We had the bacon Mac and cheese pie.
Update: went back and had the white pizza and the garlic Parmesan wings — AMAZING!!!! Best wings ever!
The employees are friendly and helpful. All of this in a fun atmosphere.
Updated from previous review on 2022-07-23
Pros: All vegan pizza, Great atmosphere , Friendly staff
Guest
The_Inked_Bird
Points +359
Its out of this world - Edit
They make their own cheese in house and it melts! The seitan pepperoni is so good
Read morePros: Homemade vegan cheese
Guest
For Members
Why was my review removed? Guidelines for writing a review View our privacy policyFor Business Owners
Claim this business
See inaccurate information? Submit an update here Link to this page from your site See an unfair review? View full terms & conditionsThis page has been viewed 9219 times.