Welcome! Let's get this started.
Finish logging in.
Serves meat, vegan options available. In early-2018 this shop began offering several vegan pizzas by the slice or by the pie to-order. Example of choices include sunflower seed cheese on pizza, margarita pizza, and vegan truffle cheese with alfredo sauce and caramlized onion. Open Mon-Sun 10:30am-12:00am.
-
413 8th Ave, New York City, New York, USA, 10001
-
Loading...
-
- Wheelchair accessible
- Accepts credit cards
- Free Wi-Fi
-
-
Last update on 08 Apr 2024 by JoãoLoureiro
Update business info -
Are you the owner?
Claim this business -
Added by BriggitteJ on 18 Apr 2018
-
-
131 Reviews
First Review by evahelgad
izzys
Points +598
Great range of vegan options - Edit
For a pizza place that uses meat, it was surprisingly good for vegans. There were plenty of options available and we ended up going back for a second slice!
Read moreUpdated from previous review on 2026-01-22
Pros: Great range of vegan options
Cons: Not completely vegan
Guest
emily_r0ach
Points +880
Great pizza - Edit
Popped in as a quick snack before our hockey game, great pizza- I tried the classic NY slice which was super tasty!
Read moreWould return
Very friendly staff and great location
Guest
agolight
Points +583
Best quick snack! - Edit
We stopped in on a Saturday morning after our train got in, super convenient location! We got the veggie medley (no cheese) and 2 other more classic slices with vegan cheese, everything was great. The veggie medley was especially filling with the perfect dough/rise. Staff was very friendly, highly recommend!
Read morePros: Variety , Friendly staff , Condiment station
Guest
KristinaEatsPlants
Points +7028
Classic NY Slice 🍕 - Edit
Pretty tasty NY-style pizza! They have a few vegan options, which is always nice to see. I’ve tried a couple of their vegan slices, and they were both flavorful and satisfying — definitely hits the spot when you’re craving a classic New York slice!
Read moreGuest
frugalnycvegan
Points +58
Best vegan pizza in nyc - Edit
When friends from out of town visit, I always bring them here
Read moreGuest
Amyladedada1
Points +906
Perfect New York slice - Edit
Looking for a slice of New York? NY Pizza Supreme has it covered. Delicious pizza served quickly and hot.
Read moreGuest
TierraJade
Points +872
NY style bucket list - Edit
I was looking to partake in some veganized New York traditions. Pizza was at the top of my bucket list. This place was exactly what I was looking for. They had 3 vegan options. Looking at pics from precious reviews, it looks like they offer different options on different days. I bought 2 slices with the intention of eating the second slice the next day. The second slice did not survive the night. It was soo good.
Read morePros: More than 1 vegan option, Fast and friendly service
Guest
RobertaCalce
Points +4899
Very good - Edit
Pity they just had one options out of several on menu. Very good slice
Read moreGuest
CrunchySpice
Points +174
Nostalgic!!! - Edit
I grew up eating NY slices, and these really hit the spot. I especially like their vegan white.
Read moreI don't love midtown, but I do love these slices. This place is my top choice for a bite in the area. Also, if you have an out of town, vegan guest, this is the place to take them for that MY pizza experience
Guest
TomRegan
Points +52
A genuinely authentic vegan NY slice - Edit
Pizza Suprema pulls of the seemingly impossible - it offers up a genuinely authentic vegan NY slice. While selection will vary depending on when you visit, I tried both the vegan classic and margheritas, and both were phenomenal.
Read moreGuest
GabieOBrien
Points +52
Delicious Pizza! - Edit
I had the vegan margarita and Alfredo pizza and both slices were huge and soooo good. I believe there were a few more vegan options that I want to try next time! Exactly the way I expect a slice of pizza to taste in NYC! A little on the expensive side but again the slices are huge so I felt it was worth it. A whole pie is like $42/$45 .
Read morePros: Good amount of options, Big slices, Delicious
Cons: Expensive
Guest
SJ738
Points +474
Best NY Pizza - Edit
Favorite NY pizza by the slice! They usually have 3-6 vegan options, and their vegan cheese is delicious! Convenient location right outside Penn Station.
Read moreGuest
gabrielleelyse
Points +78
REAL NY pizza made vegan!!. LOVE The Vegan White - Edit
So many vegan options!! My favorite is the vegan white. I also had the vegan regular slice and the sauce was so good!! I love that the vegan sauces are also homemade!! YUM!
Read moreJust beware that the sauces are made with cashew (and macadamia on some) - in case you have a food allergy!
Updated from previous review on 2025-06-01
Pros: REAL NY pizza made vegan!!!, Homemade sauce, Delicious vegan cheese
Cons: One slices leaves me wanting a whole pie 😅😫🤰
Guest
JoanaFeineis
Points +42
Super lecker! - Edit
Die Pizzen sind unglaublich lecker, mehrerr veganr sorten
Read morePros: Geschmack , Angebot, Preise
Guest
m1234567890
Points +61
Vegan pizza by the slice! - Edit
Went there during the lunch rush and saw 4 different types of vegan pizzas offered by the slice. Would go there again.
Read moreGuest
RachoDix
Points +123
yummy!!! - Edit
the Margherita pizza was really good
Read moreGuest
vegangrocerygrabs
Points +1770
Vegan Slices! - Edit
Went around closing and they only had vegan margarita slices left. Honestly was super impressed with the pizza! It was my first ever experience with NY pizza and I think I'm forever changed. The sauce was to die for, crust amazing, the vegan cheese nothing to write home about (but honestly what is new). Wish I could've gone back at an earlier time to try the other combinations, but I'm happy I got to go at least once!
Read moreGuest
MattChester
Points +3167
Best classic vegan by the slice - Edit
Thrilled the reviews led me here. It was worth it! And worth noting: very helpful and patient customer service. Never felt rushed
Read moreGuest
AmandaJean
Points +776
Vegan Pizza! - Edit
While in the city I try to only support fully vegan restaurants since there are so many but we really wanted classic NY style pizza and the vegan joints were nowhere near our hotel/planned activities so we decided to try Pizza Suprema for lunch and they did not disappoint! We tried the white, margarita, classic and alfredo. The classic wasn't anything special but the other three were all WOW, so good. The crust was so crispy and the flavors were perfect. The "cheese" wasn't anything fancy but they used the right amount and the sauces and toppings complimented it perfectly. Like a lot of NYC restaurant it's small and the process for ordering is a little chaotic but it is definitely worth it.
Read moreAmeisherry
I would totally recommend coletta , it’s a fully vegan restaurant and the owner is Italian, I had their vegan gluten free margarita pizza it was amazing , from this spot it’s 8 mins drive and 25 mins walk to coletta , if you don’t want to walk so far I believe they have Uber eats can directly deliver to your hotel . I truly love their food :)
Read moreGuest
niaz
Points +31
Ok pizza - Edit
Are okay but they’re not made fresh. I think they might be in the cabinets for a long time and then they reheat them. 
Read morePros: Lots of vegan choices, Fast service , Freindly staff
Cons: Not fresh , No mock meat options, Very dry
Guest
SoyKal-El
Points +7019
Great vegan options - Edit
It’s cool to have an authentic NY pizza place have vegan options. Overall a good price-to-value ratio and worth a stop
Read moreUpdated from previous review on 2025-03-22
veganqueenofqueensnyc
Screamers is much, much better.
Read moreSoyKal-El
True! Had been recommended here but Screamers is definitely better
Read moreGuest
trenityw
Points +1029
WOW - Edit
The vegan white slice slapped so hard, I would come back to NYC just for this pizza. Must stop by
Read moreGuest
Vancityveganeats
Points +535
Amazing vegan slices and selection - Edit
Amazing slice options! Thin, crispy, delicious
Read morePros: Lots of options , Great flavours
Guest
charlotteeedunn
Points +458
Best pizza I’ve had in NY - Edit
The pizza was so good! I’ve been to NY a few times and this is one of the best pizzas I’ve had!
Read moreGuest
CRoh
Points +24
Fine pizza - Edit
Had the vegan alfredo pizza and vegan margherita pizza. It was fine pizza but they use way too much vegan cheese and it ruins the flavor of the pizza with how slimy it is. Not my preference for pizza but it's worth trying.
Read moreGuest
hladny_vegan
Points +450
Came back twice, best vegan pizza slices - Edit
I have tried multiple pizza places with vegan options but the white-based pizza I tried here was definitely the best!
Read moreGuest
AnitaDollar
Points +5797
Lovely!! - Edit
I enjoyed the vibes and pizza here A LOT! It really feels like going to an Italian-American place ran with passion
Read moreGuest
For Members
Why was my review removed? Guidelines for writing a review View our privacy policyFor Business Owners
Claim this business See inaccurate information? Submit an update here Link to this page from your site See an unfair review? View full terms & conditionsThis page has been viewed 0 times.