Bakery

Manhattan vegan bakery est. 2005 as formerly Babycakes and re-branded in 2014 to include one of the founder's namesake. Tiny place but offers a varied selection of fully gluten-free sweets like vegan donuts, cookies, and banana bread. Reported closed October 2024.


90 Reviews

First Review by Erin P.

azoraa

Points +70

Vegetarian
18 Nov 2009

Not worth it

This is the kind of place you visit once to see it and never return again. The cupcakes are small as the ones you could bake at home in a toaster oven (which I do). Yes, some varieties contain "expensive" ingredients like agave nectar for sweetener (which they charge even more for). But that does not justify the insane prices for what you get. If you are on a budget, I recommend you come in right after a large meal and buy the bite-size brownie mini-cupcake (micro cupcake more like it) for about a buck!

Pros: Cute shop, Fair selection

Cons: Insane prices

andrea

Points +716

Vegan
06 Nov 2009

Dryyyy

I know some people love this place, and if i were gluten-free I might too. But if you aren't don't bother. The cupcakes are just so-so and other things tend toward the dry side.

·X·

Points +26779

Vegan
25 Sep 2009

An Option

I was told Babycakes was the go-to bakery in NYC for Vegans. I stopped by there twice during my visit, mainly because I wanted to give it a second chance after my first. During my first visit I got the red velvet cupcake and a chocolate chip cookie. The frosting of the cupcake and cookie both were good, but the cupcake itself was very dry, flavorless, and just disappointing. I decided to go back a few days later and got the vegan donut and a cookie cream sandwich. The donut was soft and cake-like (not the Dunkin Donuts type), it was also very small. I like both of items a lot, so this more than made up for my first visit; however those two items cost $9 and I didn't like them enough to spend that amount there on a regular basis. I did find better tasting baked goods in NYC, so BC wouldn't be my go-to place, but merely an option.

philjdomm

Points +945

Vegan
24 Jun 2008

finally, not too heavy bakeries and pastries

go for the "tops" in case the muffins are too heavy.
banana bread was slightly flaky but that's authentic vegan.
too bad most desserts dont do carob though.

GoatxThrower

Points +42

Vegetarian
02 Jun 2008

Good stuff in the L.E.S.

This place isn't bad at all, I just wish it wasn't so expensive! The coffee was awesome too.

condekedar

Points +9962

Vegan
27 Mar 2008

Cute place, good sweets

This is a cute little bakery with a great selection of muffins, cakes, brownies and cookies. Our chocolate cake and pumpkin cake were both rich, creamy and delicious. Service was super-friendly. My only complaint is that the place gets crowded awfully easily and there's only space for about six people to sit (and even then you'll be bumping elbows and brushing up against other patrons). This is a perfect place for take-out vegan sweets, but not as good as a cafe---that said, they bake wonderful desserts and you'll be tempted to take home a variety of different treats.

Pros: Prices, Service, Taste

Cons: Limited seating

baratron

Points +114

Vegan
17 Feb 2008

You won't BELIEVE they're vegan!

Oh My God. The cakes in this place are AMAZING. I haven't honestly tasted cakes that good since I had to give up dairy, and I do a lot of baking! The cakes I make are considered pretty good, but they're nothing compared to this. I haven't EVER had a cupcake with rich, fudgey, cream cheese-type frosting before. As for the brownies made with agave instead of refined sugar... out of this world!

Bear in mind that I'm from London, which is apparently the second most expensive city in the world to live in. So US $3.50 for a medium-sized cupcake seems fair game to me - I'm used to spending £2 on a cake of similar size at home. But yeah, I spent about $20 in total, and was satisfied for the next few days. Mmmm :)

Pros: So good you won't believe it's vegan

Cons: Expensive for North Americans

vegantraveler

Points +123

Vegan
26 Jan 2008

My only reason to live!

Truly one of the GREAT Joys in this world..enough said:)

Pros: Lemon Aid Cupcake, Cupcake Tops, T-Shirts

Erin P.

Points +76

Vegan
24 Oct 2007

Good but not worth the price

$3.50 for one cupcake? Come on. It was good but not that good. We were sorry we made the trek out to Babycakes. I think it's great that they exist and offer nice vegan treats, but I think a fair price is closer to $1.95 for one cupcake. We got better desserts at Cafe Viva, Zen Palate, and Teany.

Cons: haughty staff, small and cramped




This page has been viewed 23030 times.