Welcome! Let's get this started.
or
Finish logging in.
Vegan
Pizza
Italian
Beer/Wine
Delivery
Take-out
Gluten-free
Vegan Italian cuisine including pasta, “steak,” “chicken,” risotto, gluten-free pizza, and desserts such as tiramisu and panna cotta. Open since Feb ''22. Open Mon-Thu 4:30pm-10:00pm, Fri 4:30pm-10:30pm, Sat 11:30am-10:30pm, Sun 11:30am-10:00pm.
-
365 3rd Ave, New York City, New York, USA, 10016
-
Loading...
-
- Accepts credit cards
-
-
Last update on 20 Aug 2025 by Poundie
Update business info -
Added by Poundie on 11 Feb 2022
-
-
190 Reviews
First Review by sophiasinclair
MichaelSwistara
Points +170
A new favorite--the best vegan italian food - Edit
After visiting Coletta NYC last week, it has rocketed to near the top of my list for favorite restaurants. It's expensive, so it won't become a regular go-to. But for special occassions I can think of nowhere better. The food is to die for. Easily the best spaghetti carbonara I've had in many years, and the sausage ravioli was excellent. The cheese platter blew my mind, and the tiramisu was a great choice for dessert.
Read morePros: All of the pasta dishes were divine, Great cocktail list, The tiramisu!
Cons: Pricey
CityRootsNYC
Satisfying your taste buds is our ultimate goal. Glad you enjoyed your time with us. We look forward to serving you again in the future at one of our sister locations Anixi, Willow and Beyond Sushi 37th Street. Have a nice day!
Read moreGuest
McMallory
Points +2861
You will over order! - Edit
Everything here is so good. We came for the cheese plate because we had heard incredible things about the brand of blue cheese they’re carrying here (from Climax Foods) but the cheese was only the beginning of an incredible meal. All the cheeses on the plate were amazing and the spicy pepperoni was also fun. We tried the steak tartare for a starter and it was bonkers. I don’t know how they did it but it was so spot on (we had an omnivore at the table who agreed). My friend started with the meatballs and the portion was enormous and came with four huge garlic knots.
Read moreFor mains our group chose three types of pasta and one pizza and everything was outrageously good, but I admit my carbonara defeated me and I had to bring most of it home. I was sad we overordered because I was looking forward to a tiramisu. I just couldn’t do it though.
The only weak link was my cocktail. My friends’ drinks were all good or great but I chose wrong with the Nuts and Berries. It was too sweet and the heavy cream on top was too thick and flavorless. Next time I would order something different.
The staff was so kind. One member of our party had an emergency and ran very late but they were nice about it and accommodated us even though we lingered a long time over drinks waiting for her. From such a busy place I kind of didn’t expect that kindness but the staff was wonderful.
Absolutely blows other vegan Italian options I’ve been to out of the water. I will definitely be back!
CityRootsNYC
You’ve gone the extra mile to write a good note. We see that and really appreciate it. Friends like you really make this a fun business to be in. Thank you so much for your support and realness. We would love to see you at one of our sister restaurants, Anixi, Willow and Beyond Sushi 56th Street.
Read moreGuest
carmona
Points +104
Delicious! - Edit
I ordered the 3 “cheese” ravioli and it tasted AMAZING! The tomato sauce was delicious :)
Read moreMy husband ordered the truffle pasta and it was delicious as well.
The ambiance is so cute and cozy!!!!
We will definitely come back.
CityRootsNYC
Thank you for your support and your realness. We would love to see you at one of our sister restaurants, Anixi, Willow and Beyond Sushi 37th Street.
Read moreGuest
DanielleHenderson
Points +54
Outstanding vegan Italian! - Edit
My wife and I recently visited NYC and ended up having dinner at Coletta three times within a week because we just couldn't get enough.
Read moreAcross the three nights we sampled the lemon ricotta toast, crispy calamari, garlic knots, fig jam and prosciutto pizza, chickn spiedini, salmon and polenta special, squid ink ravioli, campanelle al tartuffo, carbonara, tiramisu and the dark chocolate and lavender lava cake.
Every single dish was delicious and I would eat again in a heart beat, but our stand outs were definitely the squid ink ravioli and the campanelle al tartufo, which were just outstanding. I would give a special mention to the carbonara which I think any meat eater would enjoy - I still can't quite fathom how they made it like that while still being vegan, my mind was blown, and the lemon ricotta toast which I wasn't sure about on first bite but the more you eat , the more you begin to understand the complexities of the flavours and wonderful balance of sweet, salty and citrus.
I would rank Coletta as my favourite restaurant worldwide so far and will be back in a heartbeat should I have the opportunity!
Pros: Food is amazing , Great atmosphere , Staff are lovely
CityRootsNYC
You’ve gone the extra mile to write a good note. We see that and really appreciate it. Friends like you really make this a fun business to be in. We would love to see you at one of our sister restaurants, Anixi, Willow and Beyond Sushi 37th Street.
Read moreGuest
WendiLilly-Bare
Points +144
Delicious - Edit
Took my non vegan parents for dinner and we all loved it!
Read morePros: Ravioli was so good, Many options, Intimate setting
CityRootsNYC
Thank you for your support and your realness. We would love to see you at one of our sister restaurants, Anixi, Willow and Beyond Sushi 56th Street.
Read moreWendiLilly-Bare
We have been to Beyond Sushi and loved it as well!
Read moreGuest
Reneemarie88
Points +110
Amazing food! - Edit
I will definitely be back! The chikn and raviolis were so good!!!
Read moreCityRootsNYC
Thank you for your support and your realness. We would love to see you at one of our sister restaurants, Anixi, Willow and Beyond Sushi 37th Street.
Read moreGuest
JulianaCasati
Points +5345
Creative and delicious pizzas - Edit
Coletta is such a beautiful restaurant. The menu is quite extensive so it was very difficult to choose what to eat. We ordered two pizzas to share: the potato and rosemary and the fig jam and "prosciutto". I've never tasted pizzas like these ones before. Both of them had a perfect mix of sweet and savory elements that I never thought would go well together. They were really tasty, every bite was an explosion of interesting flavors. The quality of the ingredients was noticeable. Even though the pizzas are expensive, they are quite big and fulfilling. I think that one pizza is not enough for two people, but it is definitely way more than enough for one person. I was so full afterward that I didn't have room for dessert, which I was really looking forward to. Well, next time!
Read moreCityRootsNYC
You’ve gone the extra mile to write a good note. We see that and really appreciate it. Friends like you really make this a fun business to be in. We would love to see you at one of our sister restaurants, Anixi, Willow and Beyond Sushi 56th Street.
Read moreGuest
622chaos
Points +108
premium vegan italian - Edit
best vegan restaurant i've ever been to. Everything I had was top tier
Read moreCityRootsNYC
Greetings! Hope you are having a cheerful day. Thank you for your kind words - we really appreciate it. Please join us for a meal at one of our sister locations Anixi, Willow and Beyond Sushi 56th Street. See you again!
Read moreGuest
hellohappyvegan
Points +933
Coletta was met with an absolute delight! - Edit
As an Italian vegan, my anticipation for dining at Coletta was high. Accompanied by my sister, the experience turned out to be an absolute delight.
Read moreMy inclination for housemade sodas led me to savor the Strawberry Lemon Mint Housemade Soda ($6). Its harmonious blend of sweet and tangy notes was thoroughly enjoyable.
The Puttanesca “Meatballs” ($18) set a flawless tone for our meal. These meatballs remarkably mirrored the flavors of our childhood favorites. The capers and olives elevated the dish, while the garlic knots were impeccable.
Opting to share, we ordered the House Salad on the side. Its portion exceeded expectations, offering fresh greens laced with a bold white balsamic vinaigrette. The sprinkle of parmesan on top was a tasteful touch.
For the main course, my sister selected the Rigatoni alla Norma ($26). She enjoyed the freshness of the pasta and appreciated the well-balanced sauce that avoided excessive acidity. A slightly milder level of saltiness and larger eggplant pieces would have made it even more ideal.
I savored the Wild Mushroom Truffle Pizza ($25). Having craved this combination for a while, the pizza surpassed expectations. The dough was soft, while the crust was bubbly and crunchy. Each bite unfolded a harmonious medley of sweet and savory flavors, accompanied by creamy and crunchy textures. The abundant mushroom topping and the kick of red pepper flakes elevated the experience. Although a subtle saltiness was present, it remained irresistible. Pairing it with a hint of the salad added a complementary touch.
OVERALL THOUGHTS:
The hostess, bartender, and servers demonstrated genuine kindness and attentiveness. The ambiance was a seamless blend of cleanliness and modernity, with a touch of comfort. The highlight for me was the enchanting music that transported me momentarily to Italy. Our dishes were served promptly and maintained an impressive level of freshness. A return visit is unquestionable.
Coletta proved to be a haven for Italian vegan cuisine, with standout dishes that, while occasionally slightly salty, tantalized the taste buds with their authentic flavors and thoughtful pairings.
My true rating is 4.5
EXTRA:
The tables were extremely close together
Very dim lighting
GF options
Kosher
We made a reservation
Pros: Fresh food, So many good options / thoughtful pairings, Friendly and Fast Service
Cons: On the pricey side, Some dishes ate on the salty side
futureghosts
Wow this was so cool to see, thanks! I grew up here in NY & since becoming vegan I find it hard to get proper Italian food made plant-based. John’s on 12 St is a classic NY eatery but have to say I’m not crazy about it. Will definitely check this place out. 😋
Read moreCityRootsNYC
Thank you for taking the time to give us some stars. We always try to reach for the stars. We want to aim higher. We have taken your comments to our team and hope to give you a better experience in the future.
Read moreGuest
Martusia
Points +521
Best Vegan pizza ever! - Edit
If you are on NYC and you love pizza you simply cannot miss this place!
Read morePros: Great pizza!, Super service!, Good wine!
Cons: Cannot find anything …
CityRootsNYC
Hey thanks for that! We promise to provide great food and service and a fun environment all the time. please check out our sister restaurants Anixi, Beyond Sushi Upper East Side and Willow. We can’t wait to see you back soon.
Read moreGuest
Noodlegirl
Points +348
Outstanding Italiano - Edit
The fettuccini Alfredo was delicious and so was my friend’s eggplant lasagna. Side salad excellent.
Read moreCan’t wait to return and try more dishes!
Pros: Food tasty and excellent, Service good , Wine good
Cons: Music a little too loud
CityRootsNYC
Thank you for taking the time to write this review. We greatly appreciate your feedback as it is the only way we can grow. We look forward to serving you again in the future in one of our sister locations, Anixi, Willow and Beyond Sushi 37th Street . Have a nice day!
Read moreGuest
portiii
Points +772
Amazing for special occasions - Edit
The food and drinks were absolutely delicious! The restaurant was also really cute! It was however a bit more expensive than what we were used to spending on a dinner but for a special occasion it is definitely worth it!
Read moreCityRootsNYC
We can always try harder to fulfill your needs. What we plant now, we will have to harvest later. Please come back so we can turn that into 5 stars.
Read moreGuest
stefanietravels
Points +581
Unbelievable vegan Italian - Edit
Brought some non-veg friends and they could not stop raving. Truly amazing food! Had such a hard time deciding what to order because it all sounded so so good. We all shared the calamari and a side a broccolini to start. Then squid ink ravioli, sausage and artichoke pizza, and a pasta. Tiramisu for dessert. Could not recommend enough.
Read moresamantha121
Great review! I will have to visit!
Read moreCityRootsNYC
Satisfying your taste buds is our ultimate goal. Glad you enjoyed your time with us. Please check out our sister restaurants Willow, Anixi and Beyond Sushi 37th Street. We look forward to serving you again in the future. Have a nice day!
Read moreGuest
sharonrader
Points +174
Fantastic Italian food - Edit
Coletta is a well designed, ambient and relaxing space. The food is top notch as well as the drinks. Really loved the lemon ricotta toast, but everything was extremely delicious, and the tiramisu to die for.
Read morePros: Great menu, Love the interior lighting
CityRootsNYC
Greetings! Hope you are having a cheerful day. Thank you for your kind words - we really appreciate it. Please join us for a meal at one of our sister locations Anixi, Willow and Beyond Sushi 37th Street. See you again!
Read moreGuest
vagovegano
Points +6026
Top vegan Italian… - Edit
Probably one of the top vegan Italian restaurants I’ve tried so far. Everything, and I mean everything, was delicious. Ambience and service were excellent. I would definitely come back to try other items on their menu. Favorites were the Spaghetti Carbonara and the Ravioli al’ Uovo.
Read morePros: Delicious food , Wonderful service
Cons: Pricey
CityRootsNYC
Thank you for your support and your realness. Please join us for a meal at one of our sister locations Willow, Anixi and Beyond Sushi 37th Street.
Read moreGuest
kale_queen
Points +474
Love - Edit
I LOVED it. We got the calamari to share. My friend got the chicken parm which was really good. Another friend got the sausage ravioli which was amazing. Another friend got the vodka pasta which I liked but they didn’t so much. We also got the tiramisu which was just okay. However, I got the special steak, which was AMAZING. I hope they add something like that to the menu. I’d love to go back.
Read moreCityRootsNYC
Greetings! Hope you are having a cheerful day. Thank you for your kind words - we really appreciate it. Please check out our sister restaurants, Willow, Anixi and Beyond Sushi Herald Square.
Read moreGuest
CelinaB13
Points +879
Just...WOW - Edit
I went to Coletta a while back and had the gnocci (before the new menu) and the chocolate budino. It was very delicious. I liked the smaller pprtion size and it was satisfying 👌
Read moreWent for the new menu and was blown away by how tasty and fresh everything was! The ravioli al uovo was surreal-- I haven't had eggs in 6 years and the way the vegan "yoegg" was runny and smelled like eggs was wild! The fig and feta salad was a great way to start the meal and was light and delicious.
The wild mushroom truffle pizza was fantastic and the fig Jam and prosciutto pizza was great as well. I have a preference for mushrooms in general 🍄
Tried all the ice cream and all yummy-- the hazelnut was my favorite!
Panna Cotta absolutely divine. Must order.
Biscottis were small and delicious. Great to order with an ice cream. They were more tender than crunchy which I loved.
Pros: Delicious food, Fresh pasta!, Creative dishes
CityRootsNYC
Your validation is what keeps us going - we are in the business of being compassionate and your support makes a huge difference. Please check out our sister restaurants Willow, Anixi and Beyond Sushi 37th Street. Have a great day!
Read moreCelinaB13
Love willow and beyond sushi! Anixi is on my list. I've heard amazing things. Can't wait to try the vegan labneh! It's the only thing I haven't found vegan that I miss
Read moreGuest
lilmammal
Points +275
High quality food and environment - Edit
Amazing selection. Everything we had was delicious. The mock meat dishes were our favorite.
Read moreCityRootsNYC
Your validation is what keeps us going - we are in the business of being compassionate and your support makes a huge difference. Please check out our sister restaurants, Willow, Anixi and Beyond Sushi 37th Street. Have a great day!
Read moreINTJ_mara
Oh boy, that “meat” looks a bit too real 😨
Read moreGuest
XenaWarriorPrincess
Points +3305
Excellent vegan Italian food - Edit
Absolutely blown away by my experience at Coletta! My non-vegan friends loved it as well - they couldn't even tell the food was fully plant-based. The ambiance feels like an upscale Italian restaurant. They have many pasta and pizza dishes, as well as appetizers, scrumptious desserts, and classy cocktails and wines.
Read moreI got the oyster mushroom "calamari", truffle pizza, and tiramisu. The highlight of the meal was definitely the truffle pizza - they're so generous with the toppings, and the crust was crispy on the outside, soft on the inside. Definitely one of the best pizzas I've ever had! The "calamari" flavor, texture, and mouthfeel felt convincingly real. The tiramisu was not authentic (more of a fluffy cream with cookie crumble) but delicious nonetheless.
It's not cheap though; prepare to spend about 60$ per person. Service was quite slow, even though it was a Monday night and not particularly busy.
Overall though, I would highly recommend this restaurant to anyone - vegans, veg-curious, and meat-eaters alike!
Updated from previous review on 2023-05-23
CityRootsNYC
You’ve gone the extra mile to write a good note. We see that and really appreciate it. Friends like you really make this a fun business to be in. Please join us for a meal at one of our sister locations Willow, Anixi and Beyond Sushi 37th Street.
Read moreGuest
mazinha
Points +342
It’s ok. - Edit
We were very excited to try this place and left pretty disappointed. Had the tuna carpaccio special, which was great, but everything went downhill from there: the mushroom pizza was made with daiya cheese (or a similarly horrible brand that doesn’t melt) and the crust was oily, while the tiramisu was extremely sweet. We were looking for a competitor to our favorite vegan pizza spot in the East Village but this wasn’t even close.
Read moreWe also had the risotto, which was fine but unremarkable.
Cons: Expensive , Use daiya Cheese
CityRootsNYC
Please reach us at info@colettanyc.com so we can hopefully make things better. We look forward to hearing from you.
Read moreGuest
sallweis
Points +78
Amazing if you’re not terribly hungry - Edit
The food was delicious an oh-so-fresh and the service was flawless, however, the amount of food on the plate was about 20% short of satisfactory.
Read morePros: Delicious
Cons: I’m still a little hungry
CityRootsNYC
Read moreWe appreciate your time in writing us a review. We look forward to serving you again in the future. Have a nice day!
Guest
JPDJr
Points +184
All Vegan, All Good - Edit
Kind of place you could bring carnivores. The "calamari" was crispy with just the right chew (King Mushroom rings) that non-vegans thought it was seafood. Great meatballs, penne alavodka, pasta alaNorma. Want to go back to try more dishes. Highly recommend.
Read moreUpdated from previous review on 2023-04-23
Pros: Vegan versions of classic Italian dishes, Great tasting food, Prompt service
CityRootsNYC
Thank you for your support and your realness.
Read moreGuest
MarkDowd
Points +118
Fabulous Italian food - Edit
Incredible food and generally superb dining experience. Lovely setting too.
Read moreCityRootsNYC
We love happy customers. Thankful that you dined with us and loved it. Don’t forget to spread the word.
Read moreGuest
andrewseffrood
Points +141
Fresh! - Edit
We had a great experience in this fine restaurant with table service. I had the beet salad and my date had the margherita pizza. Everything is vegan here so we’ll be back!
Read moreUpdated from previous review on 2023-04-07
Pros: Everything is vegan, Beautiful space, Great, friendly service
CityRootsNYC
Hey thanks for that! We promise to provide great food and service and a fun environment all the time. We can’t wait to see you back soon.
Read moreGuest
Michelle.L.
Points +969
Lovely experience - Edit
Coletta was a great place for a fancy meal before seeing a Broadway show. The restaurant is super nice. I got the Chick'n Linguini Alfredo and it was good. My server offered vegan Parmesan cheese to sprinkle on top of my pasta, which I thought was a really nice touch. I would definitely go back to Coletta, but it would not be a regular spot for me if I lived in the city because of the high prices. I definitely recommend it for a special occasion, though!
Read morePros: 100% vegan, Nice atmosphere
Cons: Expensive
CityRootsNYC
We can always try harder to fulfill your needs. What we plant now, we will have to harvest later. Please come back so we can turn that into 5 stars.
Read moreGuest
JulianS.
Points +28
Great vegan choices and amazing food! - Edit
Service was amazing and the food was great! The space was slightly crowded, however still comfortable and nice.
Read morePros: Lots of vegan options, Great service, Amazing food
Cons: Expensive, Crowded, Reservations recommended
CityRootsNYC
We can always try harder to fulfill your needs. What we plant now, we will have to harvest later. Please come back so we can turn that into 5 stars!
Read moreGuest
lamarks
Points +364
Expensive for daiya-like pizza - Edit
We were really excited to try Coletta because the pizza looked so good on here. We were so sad to see that even though it’s very expensive (esp with USD to CAD conversion) they used daiya (or another grocery brand that was not good) cheese and the crust was nothing special. If you’re drawn here for the pizza I would recommend going elsewhere. I’ve had much better for much cheaper in Toronto and in other cities.
Read morePros: Vegan Italian food, Very nice interior
Cons: They don’t have house made cheese, Expensive
CityRootsNYC
We are sorry for leaving a bad impression. Please reach us at info@colettanyc.com so we can hopefully make things better. We will definitely take care of this so that it doesn’t happen again.
Read moreGuest
For Members
Why was my review removed? Guidelines for writing a review View our privacy policyFor Business Owners
Claim this business
See inaccurate information? Submit an update here Link to this page from your site See an unfair review? View full terms & conditionsThis page has been viewed 0 times.